FDA's Flavored Vape OK Under Legal Fire: 5.2% of Teens Vape

For regulatory attorneys and compliance officers, the FDA’s authorization of flavored vaping products is under a spotlight that could reshape the legality of youth-appealing nicotine products. With the American Lung Association publicly demanding a reversal, the agency faces potential administrative reviews and litigation that could set binding precedents on how health agencies weigh harm reduction against youth protection.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s 2025 National Youth Tobacco Survey (NYTS) marks a historic low in teen tobacco use, with just 7.2% of middle and high school students reporting current use of any tobacco product, down from 11.3% in 2022. Despite this progress, nearly 2 million adolescents still consume nicotine, and e-cigarettes remain the dominant driver—5.2% of youth vape, a steep drop from 9.4% three years earlier but still the most prevalent product. The American Lung Association (ALA) immediately seized on the data to demand the FDA reverse its authorizations of flavored vaping products, pointing to the statistic that nearly 90% of young vapers choose flavored options, overwhelmingly fruit flavors. Thomas Carr, the ALA’s director of nationwide policy, framed tobacco as “the No. 1 cause of preventable death in the country,” noting that addiction almost always begins in adolescence.

“

Food and Drug Administration’s 2025 National Youth Tobacco Survey (NYTS) marks a historic low in teen tobacco use, with just 7.2% of middle and high school students reporting current use of any tobacco product, down from 11.3% in 2022.

The regulatory tension at the heart of this story is the FDA’s dual mandate under the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act: protect public health while still allowing adult smokers access to potentially less harmful alternatives. For years, the agency walked a tightrope—denying millions of flavored e-cigarette marketing applications, then beginning to authorize certain products, including menthol and other non-tobacco flavors, for manufacturers like NJOY under the premarket tobacco product application (PMTA) pathway. The ALA and other public health groups contend that any flavored product, even those aimed at adult conversion, inevitably attracts underage users. The 2025 survey offers ammunition for both sides. Youth vaping has declined by 45% since 2022, suggesting that overall declines can coexist with some flavored product availability. Yet with 89.4% of youth vapers favoring flavors, the appeal to adolescents is undeniable.

The survey also highlights a shifting product landscape: nicotine pouches (1.7%) now surpass cigarettes (1.4%) as the second most common tobacco product among teens, a trend that has emerged amid rising popularity of brands like Zyn. Cigars, smokeless tobacco, and heated tobacco products all registered at or below 1.1%, underscoring e-cigarettes’ outsized role. For public health, the persistence of 2 million youth users means that a new generation remains at risk for lifelong nicotine addiction, respiratory issues, and dual use with combustible cigarettes. The FDA itself has acknowledged that most adult smokers start before age 18, so preventing initiation is critical to long-term disease prevention.